THE COTNEY BRIEF | Construction Law Simplified October 2026

Regulatory Update

Major Changes to Federal DBE Requirements

The U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) has finalized significant changes to its Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) program, affecting contractors that participate in federally assisted transportation projects. The final rule, effective September 25, 2026, largely confirms changes initiated in October 2025 that eliminated race- and sex-based presumptions of disadvantage. The rule also establishes additional requirements for reevaluating existing certifications.

The DBE program has historically sought to increase participation by disadvantaged businesses in federally assisted highway, transit, and airport projects. Previously, federal regulations presumed that certain individuals qualified as socially and economically disadvantaged based on race, ethnicity, or sex. The revised regulations eliminate those presumptions and require individualized determinations of disadvantage.

Under the new requirements, business owners generally must demonstrate social and economic disadvantage through a personal narrative describing specific economic hardships, social barriers, or denied opportunities that impeded their education, employment, or business success. Applicants must also provide personal financial information to establish economic disadvantage. The rule requires certifying authorities to evaluate each applicant based on individual circumstances rather than presumed eligibility.

Importantly, the changes affect businesses that already hold DBE certifications. Existing certifications must undergo reevaluation under the revised standards. This does not necessarily require a complete recertification, but previously certified businesses generally must provide additional documentation establishing their continued eligibility.

The final rule establishes a December 24, 2026, deadline for state Unified Certification Programs to complete their reevaluations, although DOT may grant a one-time extension of up to 90 days for good cause. Businesses that fail to provide the required information face potential disqualification, subject to the rule’s notice and response procedures.

These changes also create potential complications for prime contractors. DBE participation frequently plays a role in subcontractor selection, bid preparation, and compliance with federally assisted construction contracts. Changes in certification status could affect how contractors document DBE participation and satisfy applicable contractual requirements. The transition also raises questions concerning existing subcontracting relationships and projects that began under the previous rules.

Although the final rule does not eliminate the DBE program, it fundamentally changes the certification process and may affect the availability of qualifying DBE subcontractors as certification authorities complete their reviews.

👉 Takeaway: Contractors involved in federally assisted transportation projects should review their existing DBE relationships and monitor the certification status of subcontractors. Prime contractors should also evaluate applicable contract requirements, confirm how DBE participation will be counted during the transition, and monitor guidance from state transportation agencies.

DBE-certified contractors should promptly review the new eligibility requirements and submit any requested documentation to avoid potential loss of certification.

Most importantly, contractors should not assume that previously approved DBE participation arrangements will automatically satisfy future contract requirements. Proactive review of certification status, bidding documents, and contractual obligations can help minimize compliance disputes, project delays, and potential financial exposure.

Case Law Update

Federal Court Limits Immigration Raids at Construction Sites

Venegas v. Homan, No. 1:25-cv-00397-JB-N (S.D. Ala. Sept. 21, 2026).

Facts: Leonardo Garcia Venegas, a U.S. citizen employed in residential construction in Alabama, filed a lawsuit challenging federal immigration enforcement practices after officers detained him during raids at construction sites. During two separate incidents in 2025, immigration officers entered private construction sites without warrants and detained Venegas despite his repeated statements that he was a U.S. citizen. On both occasions, he presented an Alabama REAL ID, but officers continued holding him while attempting to verify his immigration status.

Venegas challenged three Department of Homeland Security (DHS) practices: entering private construction sites without warrants or consent, detaining workers without individualized suspicion of unlawful immigration status, and continuing detention after workers presented evidence of citizenship or lawful presence.

Holding: On September 21, 2026, Chief U.S. District Judge Jeffrey U. Beaverstock of the Southern District of Alabama ruled that Venegas was likely to succeed in challenging the three practices under the Fourth Amendment and applicable federal regulations.

The court temporarily stayed the challenged DHS policies, finding that:

  1. Immigration officers generally cannot enter nonpublic areas of private construction sites without a warrant, consent, or another recognized legal justification.
  2. Officers cannot detain construction workers solely based on generalized assumptions about immigration status without reasonable suspicion specific to the individual.
  3. Officers cannot continue detaining workers under the challenged policy after they provide sufficient evidence of citizenship or lawful presence.

The court issued temporary relief rather than a final determination on the merits. The decision does not prohibit lawful immigration enforcement at construction sites.

👉 Takeaway: The decision reinforces that construction sites are not automatically open to warrantless immigration enforcement and that workers retain constitutional protections during immigration investigations. Contractors should establish procedures for responding to immigration agents, including designating a company representative, identifying public and nonpublic work areas, and verifying whether officers have a judicial warrant or another lawful basis for entry.

Contractors should also train supervisors to document enforcement encounters, avoid obstructing lawful investigations, and immediately contact legal counsel when questions arise regarding access to private property or employee detention.

Although the ruling remains preliminary and does not eliminate immigration enforcement authority, it provides important guidance concerning the constitutional limits of workplace raids and the rights of construction employers and their employees.

Contract Provision of the Month 

Background: Granule Loss on Asphalt Shingles

Granule loss has become an increasingly common concern among roofing contractors, particularly with shingles manufactured and installed following the COVID-19 pandemic. Contractors have reported instances of excessive granule shedding on relatively new roofs, resulting in homeowner complaints, warranty claims, and disputes over whether the condition constitutes a manufacturing defect or improper installation.

Asphalt shingles contain mineral granules that protect the underlying asphalt from ultraviolet exposure and weathering. Some granule loss is normal, particularly during transportation, installation, and the initial period following installation. However, excessive or premature granule loss may indicate a manufacturing defect, particularly when it exposes the underlying asphalt or affects the performance of the shingles.

Because installing contractors generally have no control over the manufacturing process or granule adhesion, roofing contracts should distinguish between normal granule shedding, manufacturing defects, and installation deficiencies. Contractors should also direct product-related warranty claims to the manufacturer while preserving their responsibility for workmanship.

Recommended Contract Provision

Granule Loss Disclaimer. Owner acknowledges that some granule loss or shedding is a normal characteristic of asphalt shingles, particularly during and following installation, and as a result of ordinary weathering and aging. Contractor does not manufacture the shingles and makes no independent warranty regarding granule adhesion or retention. To the fullest extent permitted by law, Contractor disclaims liability for any excessive or premature granule loss (“Loss”). The Loss shall be governed exclusively by the manufacturer’s written warranty, which shall constitute Owner’s sole and exclusive remedy against Contractor for such product defects. 

New Legislation Would Require Employers to Disclose AI Screening

Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly changing how employers evaluate job applicants and existing employees. From reviewing resumes and employment histories to analyzing background information and identifying potential risks, AI can streamline hiring decisions. However, proposed legislation could impose additional disclosure requirements on employers using these technologies.

On May 11, 2026, New York lawmakers introduced Senate Bill S10290, known as the Bossware and Oppressive Technology Act. The legislation would regulate employers’ use of electronic monitoring and automated employment decision tools, including AI systems used to evaluate job applicants and employees.

Under the proposal, employers using covered automated decision-making tools would have to notify applicants and employees at least 10 business days before using the technology to evaluate them. The notice would identify the use of the technology, explain the qualifications and characteristics being evaluated, and describe the information the system analyzes. Employers would also need to explain how individuals could request additional information or challenge certain employment decisions.

The proposed legislation extends beyond traditional hiring decisions. Its definition of employment decisions includes recruitment, promotions, discipline, termination, work assignments, and other employment-related matters. The bill also defines employee data broadly to include criminal background information, employment history, and other personal information.

Importantly, the legislation would require independent impact assessments of covered automated employment decision tools. These assessments would evaluate potential discriminatory effects and other risks associated with the technology.

Although the bill remains pending in committee and has not become law, it reflects a growing legislative interest in regulating AI in the workplace.

New York City already imposes similar requirements under Local Law 144, which took effect in 2023. That law requires employers using qualifying automated employment decision tools for hiring or promotion to conduct independent bias audits and provide advance notice to affected applicants and employees.

These developments are particularly relevant to construction contractors, many of whom use third-party platforms to screen applicants, evaluate employment histories, and conduct background checks. Contractors may not realize that hiring software incorporates AI to rank candidates, identify perceived risks, or recommend employment decisions.

It is important to distinguish these proposals from existing federal requirements. The Fair Credit Reporting Act already requires employers to provide disclosures and obtain written authorization before obtaining employment background reports from consumer reporting agencies. Employers must also follow specific procedures before taking adverse action based on those reports.

AI-specific legislation could add another layer of compliance when employers use automated tools to evaluate the resulting information or otherwise assist in employment decisions.

👉 Takeaway: Employers should review their hiring and background screening practices to determine whether third-party vendors use AI or automated employment decision tools. Employers should understand what information these systems evaluate, how recommendations influence employment decisions, and whether applicable laws require advance notice, consent, or bias assessments.

Employers should also ensure that qualified personnel independently review employment decisions rather than relying exclusively on automated recommendations. As states continue considering AI-related employment legislation, transparency and human oversight will become increasingly important components of effective hiring practices.

Upcoming Speaking Engagements & Events

  • Roofing Contractors Association of Texas Expo, October 21-23, Grapevine, TX 
  • National Insulation Association Fall Meetings, October 28-29, National Harbor, MD
  • Western States Fall Board and Committee Meetings, November 2-5, Monterey, CA

Disclaimer: This newsletter is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship.

Scroll to Top