Regulatory Update
DHS Restricts Automatic Employment Authorization Extensions
Effective October 14, 2026, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) finalized its October 2025 interim rule eliminating automatic extensions of Employment Authorization Documents (EADs) for certain foreign nationals who timely apply for renewal. Previously, eligible workers could continue working while their renewal applications remained pending. Under the revised rule, affected workers may lose employment authorization when their existing EAD expires, even if they submitted a timely renewal application. Certain exceptions remain.
๐ Takeaway: Construction contractors should closely monitor employee work authorization expiration dates and encourage workers to begin renewal applications well in advance. Employers must comply with Form I-9 reverification requirements while avoiding discriminatory practices. Contractors should also anticipate potential workforce disruptions if renewal delays prevent employees from continuing to work legally.
Case Law Update
Florida Appeals Court Clarifies Retainage Obligations Following Subcontractor Termination
Case: GSD Contracting, LLC v. All American Builders & Debris Removal, Inc.
No. 4D2024-3286 (Fla. 4th DCA Oct. 14, 2026)
Facts: A general contractor terminated a subcontractor working on a hotel project and withheld $71,582.98 in retainage. The subcontract permitted termination for convenience and required payment for completed work. The general contractor argued that the subcontractor’s alleged deficiencies justified withholding payment.
Holding: Florida’s Fourth District Court of Appeal ruled that the general contractor breached the subcontract by failing to release the retainage after the contractual payment deadline 90 days after projet completion. The court also reversed a separate $45,300 award for unperformed work because the subcontract expressly prohibited such recovery. The court emphasized the plain language of the parties’ agreement.
๐ Takeaway: Terminating a subcontractor does not automatically eliminate the obligation to pay for completed work. Contractors should ensure their agreements clearly address retainage, termination rights, payment obligations, and the circumstances permitting withholding or offsetting amounts for defective or incomplete work.
Contract Provision of the Month
Background: Rooftop Material Loading and Structural Capacity
Roofing contractors frequently receive instructions from owners, general contractors, or construction managers to stage roofing materials and equipment on existing roofs. These materials may include pallets of insulation, membrane rolls, roofing tiles, and other heavy equipment. Concentrated loads can exceed the roof’s structural capacity, particularly on older buildings or structures with deteriorated decking.
OSHA regulations require employers to determine whether walking and working surfaces possess sufficient strength and structural integrity to safely support employees. See 29 C.F.R. ยง 1926.501(a)(2). OSHA also prohibits exceeding applicable maximum safe load limits when storing materials on floors within buildings and structures. See 29 C.F.R. ยง 1926.250(a)(2).
A contractor cannot necessarily avoid OSHA liability by following an owner’s or general contractor’s directions. Consequently, construction contracts should expressly address structural verification, material staging, and responsibility for loading instructions.
Sample Contract Provision:
Structural Capacity and Rooftop Loading.
Prior to directing or requiring Contractor to stage, store, or place materials or equipment on any existing roof or elevated structure, Owner or General Contractor shall provide written verification from a licensed professional engineer confirming that the structure can safely support the proposed loads, including concentrated, temporary, and dynamic loads associated with construction activities. Such verification shall identify any applicable loading limitations, restrictions, or required protective measures.
Contractor shall not be required to place materials or equipment on any roof or elevated structure without adequate verification of its structural capacity. Contractor may suspend or decline any loading activity that it reasonably believes presents a structural or safety hazard without being deemed in breach of contract. Any resulting delay or additional expense shall entitle Contractor to an equitable adjustment in the Contract Price and Contract Time, except to the extent caused by Contractor’s negligence or failure to comply with approved loading requirements.
To the fullest extent permitted by law, Owner or General Contractor shall be responsible for losses, damages, and claims arising from inaccurate structural information or loading directives that exceed verified structural limitations, except to the extent caused by Contractor’s negligent acts, omissions, or unauthorized loading activities. Nothing in this provision relieves Contractor of its independent obligations under applicable safety laws and regulations.
Limiting the Never-Ending Punch List
One of the most frustrating aspects of construction project closeout involves the never-ending punch list. A contractor completes its work, participates in a walkthrough, corrects the identified deficiencies, and requests final payment. Instead of closing out the project, the owner conducts another inspection and generates an entirely new list. This process can repeat several times, delaying payment and increasing costs.
Contractors should consider addressing this issue contractually by limiting owners to one comprehensive punch-list walkthrough.
Background
Punch lists serve a legitimate purpose by identifying incomplete or deficient work that requires correction before final completion. However, problems arise when owners, architects, or consultants continually supplement the original list with additional items.
For example, an owner might identify 20 deficiencies during the initial walkthrough. After the contractor corrects those items, a second inspection identifies 15 additional concerns. A third walkthrough produces another list. Meanwhile, the contractor incurs additional labor, mobilization, and administrative expenses.
Repeated inspections can also provide leverage in payment disputes. Owners may withhold retainage or final payment while continuing to identify relatively minor deficiencies.
Although standard construction contracts contemplate punch-list inspections, they do not necessarily limit the number of inspections or supplemental lists. Contractors should therefore establish specific closeout procedures in their agreements.
Contractual Considerations
A properly drafted provision should require the owner and its representatives to participate in one coordinated inspection after the contractor provides notice of substantial completion. Following that inspection, the owner should provide one comprehensive written punch list within a specified period.
The agreement should prohibit subsequent additions involving readily observable conditions that the owner reasonably could have identified during the initial inspection.
However, contractors should distinguish between additional punch lists and verification inspections. Owners should retain the right to verify that the contractor corrected the original deficiencies without using that inspection to identify unrelated issues.
The provision should also preserve legitimate claims involving latent defects, applicable warranties, and mandatory building code requirements.
Sample Contract Provision:
Single Punch-List Inspection. Upon Contractor’s written notice of Substantial Completion, Owner and its authorized representatives shall conduct one comprehensive walkthrough within five (5) business days. Within five (5) business days thereafter, Owner shall provide Contractor with a single written punch list identifying all incomplete or nonconforming items reasonably observable during the inspection.
The punch list shall be final concerning readily observable conditions existing at the time of inspection. Owner shall not supplement or issue additional punch lists involving conditions reasonably discoverable during the initial walkthrough.
Upon completion of the identified items, Owner may conduct one verification inspection solely to confirm their satisfactory correction. Such inspection shall not provide an opportunity to identify unrelated deficiencies.
If Owner fails to participate in the inspection or timely provide the punch list, Owner shall be deemed to have waived additional punch-list objections concerning readily observable conditions, to the extent permitted by applicable law.
Nothing herein shall waive claims involving latent defects, applicable warranties, or mandatory building code requirements. Completion of the original punch-list items shall satisfy the contractual punch-list requirements for final payment, subject to other expressly stated closeout obligations and applicable law.
๐ Takeaway: Contractors should not allow punch-list procedures to become an indefinite obstacle to project closeout and final payment. By requiring one comprehensive walkthrough, a defined deadline for identifying deficiencies, and a limited verification inspection, contractors can reduce administrative costs, prevent repeated mobilizations, and minimize payment disputes. Most importantly, contractors should negotiate these limitations before signing the contract rather than attempting to impose them after disputes arise.
Upcoming Speaking Engagements & Events
- NRCA Fall Meetings, November 9-12, Nashville, TN
- Roofers Risk and Claim Workshop, Roofing Captive, November 17-18, New Orleans, LA
- Best of Success, December 7-9, Bonita Springs, FL
Disclaimer: This newsletter is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship.